Lyrics

I should'a come home to you
Lord knows it was the right thing to do
But she held me oh so tight
Should'a could'a would'a wish I'd come home that night

But that forbidden fruit tastes so good
Now I carry this regret just like I knew I would
And there's no going back to right
Should'a could'a would'a wish I'd come home that night

Should'a told you the very next day
I wanted to but I couldn't find the words to say
And I hate to see you cry
Should'a could'a would'a now I'm living a lie

That forbidden fruit tastes so good
And I went back for more just like I knew I would
And there's no going back to right
Should'a could'a would'a wish I'd come home that night

You should'a come home to me
We were hurting everyone could see
But now there's no going back to right
Should'a could'a would'a I wish you'd come home that night

That forbidden fruit tasted so good (I tried as hard as I could)
Now you'll carry that regret like you know you should (you know I will, girl)
There'll be no going back to right (oh no!)
Should'a could'a would'a, I wish you'd come home that night (I'd come home that night)
Home that night
Home that night
Home